Evaluating the Best ISEE Prep Books
Criteria: Accuracy, Practice Tests, and Explanations
When conducting ISEE prep book reviews, the most vital metric is the accuracy of the practice material relative to the actual exam's difficulty and formatting. A high-quality book must replicate the stanine scoring environment, where a student's raw score is converted into a scaled score and then compared against a three-year rolling norm group. To prepare for this, the practice tests within a book must mirror the ISEE’s specific constraints, such as the distinct lack of a guessing penalty—a feature that differentiates it from some versions of the SSAT. Furthermore, the depth of answer explanations is paramount. Effective resources do not merely provide the correct letter choice; they offer a detailed rationalization for why specific distractors (incorrect options) are wrong. This helps students identify common traps, such as "extreme language" in reading comprehension or "computational lures" in math, where a common calculation error leads directly to one of the incorrect choices.
Matching Books to Student Strengths and Weaknesses
No single resource serves every learner perfectly, making a test prep book comparison essential for personalized study. For a student struggling with Quantitative Reasoning, a book that emphasizes logical patterns and estimation over raw calculation is necessary. This section of the ISEE often requires identifying relationships between numbers rather than solving long-form equations. Conversely, a student who excels in math but falters in the Verbal Reasoning section needs a resource focused on synonyms and sentence completions that utilize high-level academic vocabulary. The choice of book should also reflect the student’s current grade level and cognitive development. A younger student preparing for the Lower Level exam requires a more encouraging tone and larger font sizes, whereas an Upper Level candidate needs dense, rigorous material that simulates the pressure of the 160-minute testing window. Identifying these needs early allows for a more targeted acquisition of study materials.
The Role of the Official ERB Guide
The official ISEE guide published by the Educational Records Bureau (ERB) is the gold standard for authenticity. Unlike third-party publishers who must reverse-engineer questions, the ERB provides the only retired questions that have actually appeared on previous iterations of the exam. This makes the official guide an indispensable tool for establishing a baseline score through a diagnostic test. Because the ISEE uses a unique scaling system—where the difficulty of the questions is calibrated using Item Response Theory—the official guide is the only source that accurately reflects the "feel" of the test's progression from easy to difficult items. While the official guide is often leaner on strategy and instructional content compared to commercial books, its value lies in its role as a benchmarking tool. Every serious preparation plan should incorporate at least one official practice test to ensure the student is not being misled by third-party materials that may be too easy or unnecessarily complex.
In-Depth Reviews: Major Test Prep Publishers
The Princeton Review: Strategy-Focused Approach
The Princeton Review is widely recognized for its emphasis on "cracking" the test through systematic elimination and strategic guessing. Their approach to the ISEE focuses heavily on the Process of Elimination (POE), teaching students to identify and discard "attractor" choices designed to fool the unwary. For instance, in the Reading Comprehension section, they train students to look for the Main Idea by scanning for structural signposts rather than getting bogged down in every detail. Their books typically include multiple full-length practice tests that are slightly more difficult than the actual exam, which can build stamina. However, some educators note that their math strategies sometimes prioritize shortcuts over foundational understanding. This makes their guides ideal for students who already have a strong academic grasp but struggle with the specific mechanics of standardized testing or suffer from test anxiety.
Kaplan: Comprehensive Content Review
Kaplan’s resources are often viewed as the most balanced option for students who need a mix of content instruction and practice. Their ISEE materials provide a thorough review of the mathematical concepts tested, ranging from basic arithmetic to higher-level algebraic functions and geometry. Kaplan utilizes a "Learn, Practice, Check" methodology that ensures a concept is mastered before the student moves on to more complex applications. Their ISEE Middle Level workbook is particularly well-regarded for its clear breakdown of the Quantitative Reasoning section, which many 7th and 8th graders find challenging due to the introduction of abstract logic problems. Kaplan’s practice questions tend to be very close in difficulty to the actual ISEE, avoiding the frustration of overly obscure questions. This makes it a reliable choice for a broad range of students who need to solidify their core knowledge while learning the ISEE’s specific layout.
Barron's: Rigorous Practice and Drills
Barron’s is synonymous with academic rigor, often providing practice problems that exceed the difficulty level of the actual ISEE. This "over-preparation" strategy is designed to make the real test feel manageable by comparison. Their books are characterized by dense text and a high volume of practice drills, particularly in the Verbal sections. For students aiming for the highest stanine scores (7, 8, or 9), Barron’s provides the high-level vocabulary and complex sentence structures necessary to master the Verbal Reasoning section. A potential drawback is that the difficulty can be discouraging for students who are already struggling with the material. Barron’s is best suited for high-achieving students who want to push their limits and ensure there are no surprises on test day. Their guides often include a detailed breakdown of the ISEE Essay, providing prompts and sample responses that help students understand how to structure a persuasive argument within the 30-minute time limit.
Specialized Resources for Each Test Level
Top Picks for Upper Level (Grades 9-12)
The ISEE Upper Level prep book market is the most competitive, as these students are often vying for spots at elite boarding and day schools. At this level, the exam includes advanced concepts such as matrix logic, complex probability, and sophisticated literary analysis. The best books for this level focus on the nuance of the Reading Comprehension section, where questions move beyond simple recall to inferential reasoning and identifying the author's tone. Resources like those from Ivy Global or Test Prep Works are frequently cited for their high-quality Upper Level content. These books reflect the increased length of the sections and the higher level of vocabulary expected of 8th through 11th graders. They also provide guidance on the Mathematics Achievement section, which at the Upper Level covers topics up to Pre-Calculus, requiring a resource that can explain these concepts clearly and concisely.
Recommended Books for Middle Level (Grades 7-8)
Students entering grades 7 and 8 face a unique challenge: they are often tested on material they have only just begun to cover in school. An effective ISEE Middle Level workbook must bridge this gap by providing "bridge lessons" for topics like geometry theorems and percentages. The Middle Level exam is a significant step up from the Lower Level, introducing more complex multi-step word problems. Recommended resources for this level prioritize clarity and step-by-step problem-solving. Publishers that offer modular practice—allowing students to focus exclusively on one sub-topic like "fractions and decimals" before moving to "ratios and proportions"—are particularly effective. This level of preparation is about building confidence as much as it is about content, so books that include diagnostic tools to track progress over time are highly beneficial for maintaining student motivation during the months leading up to the test.
Essential Guides for Lower Level (Grades 5-6)
The Lower Level ISEE is the first exposure many 4th and 5th graders have to formal standardized testing. Consequently, the best prep books for this age group are those that minimize intimidation. These guides focus on the fundamentals: basic reading fluency, foundational arithmetic, and the ability to follow multi-part directions. Unlike the Upper Level, where strategy is king, the Lower Level is primarily about accuracy and comfort with the format. Books that include colorful diagrams, engaging themes, and shorter practice sets help maintain the attention span of younger learners. It is also important that these guides explain the essay component in a way that is accessible, focusing on basic paragraph structure and clear handwriting. Resources tailored for the Lower Level avoid the dense, jargon-heavy explanations found in older-level books, ensuring that the student feels capable and prepared rather than overwhelmed.
Workbooks and Drills for Targeted Practice
Vocabulary Builders and Flashcard Sets
Vocabulary is often the most significant barrier to a high score in the Verbal Reasoning and Reading Comprehension sections. Because the ISEE tests Tier 2 and Tier 3 vocabulary—words that are common in academic texts but rare in everyday conversation—standard rote memorization is often insufficient. The best workbooks in this category use a "words in context" approach, teaching students to use context clues like contrast signals (e.g., "however," "despite") and continuation signals (e.g., "furthermore," "similarly"). Specialized flashcard sets are also valuable, particularly those that group words by "families" or roots (prefixes and suffixes). For instance, learning the root "ben" (meaning good) helps a student decipher words like beneficent, benign, and benediction. Dedicated vocabulary workbooks provide the repetitive exposure necessary to move these words from short-term memory to active recognition during the timed pressure of the exam.
Math Mastery Workbooks by Topic
General prep books often provide a broad overview, but many students find they need deep-dive practice in specific mathematical domains. Topic-specific workbooks allow for concentrated effort on areas like quantitative comparisons, a unique ISEE question type that asks students to determine which of two quantities is greater or if they are equal. These workbooks provide hundreds of problems dedicated to a single concept, such as number properties or coordinate geometry. This level of repetition is essential for developing "automaticity," the ability to solve basic components of a problem without conscious effort, thereby saving time for the more complex reasoning required in the Mathematics Achievement section. For a student who consistently misses questions involving circles or triangles, a geometry-specific workbook provides the targeted intervention that a general guide cannot offer.
Reading Comprehension Passage Drills
Reading Comprehension on the ISEE is not just about understanding the text; it is about answering questions within a strict time limit—roughly 35 minutes for 36 questions across 6 passages. Specialized workbooks for reading focus on active reading techniques, such as annotating the text for the author's purpose and identifying the "scope" of the passage. These drills help students distinguish between different question types, such as inference questions, which require reading between the lines, and literal comprehension questions, where the answer is stated directly in the text. High-quality reading workbooks include a variety of passage genres, including social studies, science, and humanities, mirroring the diversity of the actual test. By practicing with these drills, students learn to manage their time by deciding which passages to tackle first based on their personal comfort with the subject matter.
Creating a Multi-Book Study Plan
Using the Official Guide for Benchmarking
A sophisticated study plan begins and ends with the official guide. The first step should be a timed, proctored diagnostic exam using one of the two official tests provided by the ERB. This establishes a baseline scaled score and identifies the student’s current stanine placement. By analyzing the results of this initial test, a student can see exactly where they fall on the bell curve compared to their peers. This data is crucial for determining how much preparation is needed. If a student is aiming for a school that typically accepts applicants in the 7th stanine or above, and their diagnostic shows they are currently at a 4, the study plan must be significantly more intensive. The second official test should be reserved for the final week before the actual exam to serve as a final "dress rehearsal," ensuring the student is accustomed to the pacing and physical demands of the test.
Supplementing with Strategy and Content Books
Once the diagnostic identifies weaknesses, the student should transition to a combination of strategy and content-focused books. For example, if the diagnostic reveals a struggle with the Quantitative Reasoning section, the student might spend four weeks working through a Kaplan guide for content review, followed by two weeks of Princeton Review for test-taking shortcuts. This multi-publisher approach prevents the student from becoming too accustomed to one writer's style, which can lead to a false sense of security. It also ensures that the student is exposed to different ways of explaining the same concept. A student might find one book’s explanation of slope-intercept form confusing but find another publisher’s visual approach perfectly clear. Mixing resources ensures a more well-rounded mastery of the syllabus and helps the student develop a flexible mindset that can adapt to the varied wording of the actual ISEE.
Rotating Resources to Avoid Burnout
Preparing for the ISEE is a marathon, often spanning three to six months. To prevent cognitive fatigue, it is essential to rotate between different types of resources. A study schedule might involve vocabulary flashcards on Mondays, math drills on Wednesdays, and a full-length practice section from a different publisher each Saturday. This variety keeps the material fresh and challenges the brain to apply learned concepts in different contexts. Furthermore, rotating books allows for a "spiraling" curriculum, where the student revisits difficult topics like probability or sentence logic across different books over several weeks. This reinforcement is key to long-term retention. By the time the student reaches the final weeks of preparation, they should have a "toolbox" of strategies drawn from multiple sources, allowing them to approach the exam with a comprehensive set of skills.
What to Avoid in an ISEE Prep Book
One of the biggest risks in selecting prep materials is inadvertently using outdated editions. While the core mathematical and linguistic concepts of the ISEE do not change frequently, the test specifications and the way questions are weighted can evolve. For example, older books might still include question formats that the ERB has phased out or might not reflect the current emphasis on certain types of data analysis. Using an outdated book can lead to "negative transfer," where a student learns a strategy for a question type they will never actually encounter. Always check the copyright date and ensure the book specifically mentions the current version of the ISEE. If a book lists the SSAT and ISEE as identical tests, avoid it; while they cover similar ground, the ISEE’s unique Quantitative Reasoning section requires a different pedagogical approach than the SSAT’s math sections.
Poor Answer Explanations
A prep book is only as good as its answer key. Avoid books that provide only the correct letter (e.g., "The answer is B") without explaining the underlying logic. The goal of practice is to learn from mistakes, and without a clear explanation of the distractor analysis, a student is likely to repeat the same error. A poor resource might explain a math problem by showing the final equation without detailing the intermediate steps or the "why" behind the setup. In the Verbal section, a weak book might define the correct word but fail to explain why the other four options are less precise. Effective preparation requires understanding the nuances of synonym selection and the subtle differences between words with similar meanings. If a book’s explanations are consistently vague or overly brief, it will fail to provide the cognitive growth necessary for a top-tier score.
Inaccurate Difficulty Leveling
Finally, be wary of books that are either significantly easier or significantly harder than the actual ISEE. Some "budget" publishers produce generic materials that do not accurately reflect the norm-referenced nature of the ISEE. If a student consistently scores 90% or higher on practice tests from a specific book but then struggles with the official ERB practice material, that book is providing a false sense of confidence. Conversely, books that are needlessly difficult can cause unnecessary stress and lead to a student giving up on their preparation. The best way to verify the difficulty level of a third-party book is to cross-reference its problems with the official guide. If the vocabulary in the third-party book seems archaic or the math requires concepts far beyond the grade level (such as calculus for a Middle Level student), the resource is likely poorly calibrated and should be used with caution.